A Day at the Races
  • Home
  • Montreal Races
    • Montreal Grand Prix 2006
    • Montreal Grand Prix 2007
    • Montreal Grand Prix 2008
    • Montreal Nascar Nationwide 200 2007/08
    • Montreal Grand Prix 2010
    • Montreal Grand Prix 2011
    • Montreal Grand Prix 2012
    • Montreal Grand Prix 2013
    • Montreal Grand Prix 2014
  • Other Races
    • Melbourne Grand Prix 2004
    • Spa 2011
    • Trois Rivieres 2009
  • Tickets
    • Melbourne Albert Park
    • Montreal Circuit Gilles Villeneuve
    • Monaco
    • Trois Rivieres
    • Spa Francorchamps
  • Blog
  • Links
  • Forum
  • Contact
  • Wish List
    • Hungary

Rules put to the test

5/27/2011

0 Comments

 
The Spanish Grand Prix was meant to be the big test as to whether this years rules are working. A Grand Prix in Spain is not something which usually gets the heart pumping very quickly. It's a nice track in a nice country with nice weather and nice people but it always produces boring races. Personally, I prefer a race in Hungary to one in Barcelona although I think I may be in the minority there. This years rules had been introduced to get rid of boring races, so Spain was the perfect test for Pirelli, DRS and KERS.

KERS isn't really new but some teams are still struggling to get it working properly. I am not a big fan of KERS. I get the need for car companies to look a little environmentally friendly  while burning 100 litres of fuel in 100 minutes. But if everyone has KERS and uses it at the same time then there is no difference in speeds and KERS turns into an expensive way to get nothing done. So far this year the only time that KERS gets interesting is when it doesn't work. Thank God that Red Bull can't get Vettels KERS hooked up for a whole race. Luckily Red Bull's KERS is about as solid as a Pirelli supersoft and the fast cars get slowed down every now and again. Spain was no different with Vettels mid race KERS breakdown being the only time that you noticed KERS was in the race.

DRS seemed to be the big failure of Spain. In China and Turkey people said DRS made passing too easy but in Barcelona DRS didn't make a difference to the passing even with the longest DRS zone of the season. Although Spain had a record number of passing manouveures this year I don't recall a single DRS passing moment. Maybe instead of reducing the drag of the follwing car the FIA should look at increasing the drag of the car in front.

Where there was a lot of passing in Spain was in the back of the track where passes have never taken place before. There was a simple reason for this. Pirelli tyres. There seem to be people out there complaing about the new rules saying that they are making racing too artificial. I don't recall these same people cheering loudly at processional 2 stop races around Barcelona and Valencia in years gone by. I think it is great to see drivers like Jenson Button being able to overtake people by setting them up through the corners rather than a Tilke inspired passing under breaking after a long straight.

If Spain was the test then I would give the rules a passing grade but that is coming all on the back of Pirelli tyres. DRS and KERS and any other abbreviated device you can think of might as well be thrown away. Give me marbling
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Tony

    I am a race fan. I cannot claim to be an expert on anything, but as a fan I am apparently the most important part of the sport. So I assume everyone wants to hear what I have to say.

    Archives

    May 2014
    November 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    September 2012
    June 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011

    Categories

    All
    2011
    2011 Champion
    2012
    2013
    Australia
    Bahrain
    Belgium
    Boring
    Canada
    Cheap
    China
    Daytona 500
    Death
    Drs
    Electric Cars
    Environmental
    Equipment
    Europe
    F1
    Fans
    Fanvision
    Fia
    Flickr
    Formula 1
    Forum
    Green Flag
    Heat
    Home Race
    Kers
    Kimi
    Lotus
    Malaysia
    Melbourne
    Montreal
    Motorracing
    Nascar
    Option
    Pirelli
    Preseason
    Pre-season
    Prime
    Rain; Red Flag
    Road Car Technolgy
    Rules
    Spa
    Spain
    Summer Holidays
    Team Orders
    Technology
    Tickets
    Tilke
    Tracks
    Turkey
    Twitter
    Tyres
    Valencia
    Vettel
    Webber
    Website
    Winter
    Withdrawal

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.